Friday, April 20, 2007

The pet food scandal is now a human food scandal

This is no longer a tale about Fido and Frisky. It's about all of us.

The latest products affected by the pet food recall are eight varieties of Royal Canin dog food and one production run of Blue Buffalo kitten food, both of which used rice protein concentrate from the same supplier used by Natural Balance. (Visit the web sites for specific information.) Royal Canin and Blue Buffalo are highly regarded firms, not known for cutting corners. So far, the recall is precautionary; no animal illnesses have been traced to these products.

An Artemis spokesperson has assured me that the rice in their food comes from American sources -- which is to say, their suppliers have told the company that all the rice they ship was grown in North America. Artemis, as I've mentioned a couple of times, is the brand I feed my own ravenous beastie, and she is doing well.

In South Africa, many brands (the cheaper ones, I imagine) were affected by corn gluten tainted with melamine, imported from China. Someone should tell the South Africans that the U.S. has plenty of corn for sale.

If you don't own a pet, don't think that you can escape this sorry business. After all, pigs gotta eat too:
Hogs fed pet food rejected as unsuitable for sale ended up eating a product laced with an industrial chemical, federal authorities said yesterday, expanding a food safety investigation that had been primarily focused on cats and dogs.

It remains unclear, however, whether products made from the hogs will be considered safe for human consumption.
Most of us don't like to think about the crap we feed our livestock. Yet now we must.

Investigators suspect that the melamine was placed in the products intentionally.
The current theory is that Chinese suppliers intentionally added melamine to ingredients that were low in protein to ensure they would test high enough to allow them to be labeled as protein supplements and command the prices of wheat gluten, rice-protein concentrate, or corn gluten.
China refuses to allow American inspectors into the country. Congress has responded with the kind of bellicosity normally associated with Ned Flanders and Wally Cox:
Members of Congress, pointing to $2.1 billion in agricultural products American companies imported last year from Chinese suppliers, are pressuring the Chinese government to cooperate with the FDA.

"We strongly urge the Chinese government to quickly issue visas to US inspectors," wrote Rosa L. DeLauro, Democrat of Connecticut, and Senator Richard J. Durbin, Democrat of Illinois. "Clearly, this is an important trading relationship."
Think about it.

Ten years ago, Congress would have provided action, not whining or pleading. Congress would have temporarily banned food imports from China, and officials in that country would have quickly acceded to our reasonable requests for access.

But now...China is Sean Hannity, and we play the role of alan colmes. China has become the Drill Instructor and the U.S. is the pimply young recruit sputtering "Sir, yes Sir." Congress can, in short, do very little -- for reasons having nothing to do with party or political ideology.

China prints money to service our debt. Our economy survives or dies at their caprice. They call the shots.

6 comments:

Captain Quahog said...

I am so glad you mentioned Artemis as that is what I feed my dog as well. I was getting worried. I have started making a mixture of turkey burger, veggies, brown rice and fruit even though. She likes it so I might just change her over to it permantly.
I did a post about it a few weeks back about what they really use to make pet food. I was amazed to learn that Science Diet, Iams and Ukanuba are some of the worst dog & cat foods out there. 'It's the ingredients stupid!' If people just took the time to look at the labels of the food they are feeding their pets they would know.

Thanks Joseph for all you are doing to expose this mess.

Anonymous said...

Thanks Joe.
We just went back to cooking for our dogs after learning from this blog about Natural Balance , whom we had called when this all began, and had been assured all was well.

Fool me once..

How dog food is made:

http://iml.jou.ufl.edu/projects/Spring04/Perhach/PetFood/Processing.htm

Anonymous said...

hi yellow dog imperialists!!
from now on you will take what we give you and you will get on your knees and thank us, your new masters.
if you refuse to obey us we will simply take all your newly created debt(thanks george!)and cash in our chips.
me i likey rodeo drive houses and big buxomed blondeys.
me so horny!
now eat up imperialist pigs

Anonymous said...

A California pig farm has now been quarantined. Melamine was found in the pig's urine.

http://cbs5.com/topstories/local_story_110010818.html

Anonymous said...

Thanks Joe, Yours is one of the best blogs out there. I remember last month when the pet food contamination issue was first announced, I was telling my wife "something doesn't add up here, there's got to be more to it." Now it seems like we are treated to additional worries almost daily with all the new recalls and now it looks like people food is also affected.

After doing some research we decided to switch to Canidae dog food, which I found is carried locally by a pet "boutique" which sells alot of high-end pet products. Yesterday the ladies who run the business told me they can't keep up with demand lately.
Pete

Joseph Cannon said...

I've never tried Canidae, but I just visited their website. They don't use glutens of any sort, and they don't use corn, wheat or soybeans. Looks to me like they put out a fine product -- and you can get it for less than a dollar a pound, if you buy in bulk.

As for lee's comment: When I first looked into these matters, I was astonished to discover that some of the more costly pet foods were just as unhealthful as the cheap grocery store brands. Science Diet, Iams and Eukanuba are -- in my opinion -- loaded with stuff I would not feed to any pet, and they cost nearly as much as do the truly healthy dog foods. Like you, I'm amazed that people don't read the ingredients list.

Did you ever look at a can of Fancy Feast? Nobody should feed that stuff to any cat! And it's more expensive than an equivalent amount of human food. Just buy some cheap canned tuna and some liver. (Cats need liver, though not too much.) Throw in a little cod liver oil, some vegetable oil, maybe one of those cat vitamin supplements, maybe some ground up broccoli stalk and some egg. The result will cost half as much as some canned foods, and it's a lot better for the animal.

Cats are carnivores. There is NO reason why gluten should be in a feline diet. Frankly, they don't really need starches of any kind, although even the highest-end cat kibbles will include rice.