Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Pet food update

A while back, we had a discussion about the best menu plan for dogs. One reader stumped for the BARF (Bones And Raw Food) diet, while another suggested an all-vegetarian diet.

Well, we have a winner, because you can't argue with success. The world's oldest dog died last year at the age of 29. She was a rather large grey labrador mix (!) -- and her name was Bella. Same as my Havanese hell-hound.

Here is Bella the elder's diet:
And with most of her teeth missing [only two front teeth remaining], she can no longer manage to gnaw on the remnants of a leg of lamb. So, her diet now consists of shredded chicken, fish, boiled liver and best tinned stewing steak, mackerel and sardines.
"Best tinned stewing steak"? Hmmm. Must be a Brit thing. (Bella lived in Derbyshire.)

Years ago, I used to feed my Bella canned jack mackerel because a local store offered a full pound of the stuff for 50 cents. She loved it, and the Omega-3 oils were probably quite healthy for her. But that stuff is nasty to deal with. At the time, I could not believe that human beings -- even those in parlous circumstances -- would willingly chow down on such feed. But now, with times so lean and so many health nuts recommending fish oils, this recipe seems worth considering.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bella was 29! WOW...that's so unusual today.

Joe, although I'm the proponent of raw ground beef/chicken (mixed up with olive oil, a few ground vegetables, etc) and bone gnawing, I give my dog lots of tinned sardines and jack mackerel, as well as yogurt, a raw egg mixed in with milk, cheese, etc. Real food is good. Hope Bella is improving!

Peter of Lone Tree said...

Jack mackerel!?!
As Richard Brautigan says in his novel A CONFEDERATE GENERAL FROM BIG SUR, "Not even the cats would eat it." As I recall, the humans, faced with deep hunger were forced to, and ended up farting the night away.

Zee said...

My dog always goes nuts when I have tinned fish...loves it!

DancingOpossum said...

I've never even heard of jack mackerel.

Joseph Cannon said...

Jack mackerel: Imagine a sardine the size of a trout, with the head cut off and stuffed into a can. The bones are soft enough to eat, although you can still see the cartilage. And the smell is...

is...

...well, your dog will love it.

Anonymous said...

Although one data point should not a recommendation make, logic dictates that if an aminal's ancestors for 10 or 20 million generations had carnivore diets, that would be the best thing for it as well.

You could try to select for other diets - to force its evolution - but for a while (to say the least) you'd get a lot of animals dying sooner of various diseases before you got what you wanted.


Sergei Rostov