Saturday, December 29, 2007

Manner of death

We now have three "official" stories about the death of Benazir Bhutto: She died of a bullet wound. She died of bomb shrapnel. She died bumping her head while trying to duck out of harm's way.

I can easily imagine a situation in which all three wounds appear on her body. All three wounds would have been inflicted in very rapid order.

So how would a medical examiner determine which of the three wounds was fatal? Perhaps a reader with the proper training can enlighten us...

Larisa has some interesting commentary on the topic. She notes that the American right has begun a Bhutto-Hate campaign, which is an interesting development. From the New York Post:
In fact, Bhutto was a frivolously wealthy feudal landlord amid bleak poverty. The scion of a thieving political dynasty, she was always more concerned with power than with the wellbeing of the average Pakistani.
"The scion of a thieving political dynasty..." Oh, the irony!

Indian intelligence apparently believes that Al Qaeda is not responsible for the Bhutto hit...
“This is not the usual Al Qaeda modus operandi,” an analyst said. The Indian agencies believe the strike was rehearsed and involved several people. “It was a highly planned, highly motivated, highly integrated plan. Otherwise it wouldn’t have happened the way it did,” a senior intelligence operative told DNA.

“It was a meticulous insider job, probably. People would have been bought because massive support is needed do something like this.”

Sources said if the bomber was so close to Bhutto, the vehicle would not have survived the blast, as it did. The bomb was so powerful that the assassin’s head was found some 75 feet away from the site, according to Indian assessment.

6 comments:

Antifascist said...

Joseph writes:

"Indian intelligence apparently believes that Al Qaeda is not responsible for the Bhutto hit..."

Well, at least according to current RAW analysts. B. Raman, a former RAW analyst and high-ranking Indian government official currently writing for the South Asia Analysis Group has a different take on the Bhutto assassination. See: "Al Qaeda in GHQ, Rawalpindi," http://www.southasiaanalysis.org/papers26/paper2522.html

Thumbnail sketch: al-Qaeda has infiltrated ISI/IB power centers and may very well have high-ranking supporters amongst staff officers. Some were/are violently opposed to the proposed Musharraf/Bhutto accommodation to US GWOT aims in the region. Plausible? Perhaps...

Raman points to the lax investigation of the October assassination attempt on Bhutto as well as the still unsolved attempts on Musharraf's life, linking these events to an on-going collaboration amongst some ISI/IB officials and various jihadi outfits.

Ominously, Raman closes by stating: "If Al Qaeda is already having sleeper cells in the GHQ, there is an equal danger that it already has sleeper cells inside Pakistan's nuclear establishment too."

Even if ultra-right media mouthpieces of imperialism such as the NY Post have launched attacks on Bhutto, we should not forget that Bhutto herself was instrumental in supporting the military's "Taliban option" in Afghanistan. See: Brisard and Dasquie's "Forbidden Truth," Ahmed Rashid's "Taliban" and John Cooley's "Unholy Wars." Anyone remember the proposed Unocal pipeline deal with the Taliban, at US instigation?

The Bhutto clan is horribly corrupt: after all her husband isn't called to as "Mr. ten percent" for nothing! Does clan corruption justify political murder? Hardly. Does it absolve the military establishment? Not likely. Note the swift elimination of the crime scene by the police via high-powered hoses. How does one conduct an investigation when the evidence is gone?

Anonymous said...

This murder sounds like JFK's hit

Cascadia Green said...

In view of the fact that the authorities ignored Pakistani law and refused to do an autopsy, it's probably safe to assume that anything they say about her mode of death is suspect.

I'm a physician. I looked at the photograph of the x-ray showing her lethal skull fractures. There is no way to tell that that's even a skull, much less a human skull, much less HER skull. They cut off the facial bones and teeth which might have permitted identification.

Furthermore, allowing for the very poor quality of the photograph/x-ray, there seems to be two depressed skull fractures. Either that or two chunks of skull are missing. Impossible to say. But for her to have sustained those injuries from an impact with a sun roof lever, her skull would have had to have been as fragile as an eggshell.

She needs to be exhumed and autopsied by impartial, international forensic pathologists. Failing that, her cause of death will remain undocumented.

Respectfully,
Cascadia Green

Antifascist said...

There's a new report on the Karachi-based newspaper website "The News International," titled "Pindi Police Chief Did Not Agree to Benazir's Autopsy," http://thenews.jang.com.pk/top_story_detail.asp?Id=11974

Excerpt:

ISLAMABAD: The decision not to carry out an autopsy on the body of late PPP leader Benazir Bhutto was taken by the chief of the Rawalpindi Police, although, under the law in every murder case a medico-legal report based on a mandatory post mortem was a must, a leading lawyer and a member of the Board of Management of the Rawalpindi Medical College and the Rawalpindi General Hospital said on Saturday.

"Even if the family of a murder victim refuses to allow the autopsy, no investigation can be completed if doctors do not perform the autopsy and conclusively find the cause of death," Athar Minallah told The News, after the seven doctors who wrote the "treatment report" of late Benazir Bhutto talked to him on Saturday as he was a member of their Board of Management.

"The doctors were worried that their initial report, which did not determine the definite cause of death, is being politically twisted," Minallah said.

Sounds like a coverup to me. When will the attending physicians start to "disappear"?

Anonymous said...

Here is a bit of news footage showing man with pistol up close, five or six shots at close range as Ms Bhutto stands waving from the sunroof.

http://menorahblog.typepad.com/menorah/2007/12/breaking-bhutto.html

(May take a few minutes to download)

h/t to Uncle $cam at moonofalabama.

Antifascist said...

And this from the Uk's Channel 4 via Raw Story:

http://rawstory.com/news/2007/Video_The_most_conclusive_evidence_Bhutto_1230.html

The clearest evidence that Bhutto was shot...