Friday, May 19, 2006

The first casualty of war (Update)

Drudge, it seems, has linked to an obvious disinformation yarn about Iran: Seems the Iranian government passed a new law forcing Jews and Christians to wear identifying insignia. The rightist bloggers have been all over the story.

Obviously, if this fable had any factual basis, we would have heard about it from a government source, or from a media outlet more credible than the National Post of Canada, an ultra-conservative sheet founded by Conrad Black (who was indicted by Patrick Fitzgerald). The reports have been picked up elsewhere -- Newsmax, for example -- but the sourcing seems the same.

Is the assertion true? This news team looked into it:
But independent reporter Meir Javedanfar, an Israeli Middle East expert who was born and raised in Tehran, says the report is false.

"It's absolutely factually incorrect," he told The New 940 Montreal.

"Nowhere in the law is there any talk of Jews and Christians having to wear different colours. I've checked it with sources both inside Iran and outside."
Even the New York Sun (another rag with a "Black" background) is backing away from this one:
On Friday, the Jewish Community's representative in Iran's parliament, known as the Majlis, Morris Mohtemed spoke with the secretary general of the Iranian American Jewish Federation in Los Angeles, Sam Kermanian, and told him the story reported by the National Post in Canada today was false.
Here's the kicker: The National Post and Newsmax base their tales on reports by Iranian expatriates living in Canada. Now that's solid sourcing. To doubt those expats would be like doubting the word of...oh, I dunno. Achmed Chalabi?

We've seen this sort of thing before. When Reagan tried to drum up support for war against the Nicaraguan Sandinistas, Administration media flacks pushed a fake story of how Ortega's goons had attacked a Synagogue and persecuted Jews. For some reason, America's Bible belters -- most of whom have never attended a seder, and many of whom have a secret (sometimes not-so-secret) gut mistrust of the Jewish people -- always fall for any propaganda claptrap designed to evoke memories of the Holocaust.

Of course, if the neocons get their way, we shall have war with Iran, and that war will soon go nuclear. When mushroom clouds decorate the landsape, Iranian Jews and Christians will find themselves well beyond any sartorial worries.

Update: The National Post has removed the article. I imagine there will be formal retractions tomorrow. Of course, you know how disinfo works: A good lie leaves a stench that lingers long after exposure. In the ramp-up to current debacle in Iraq, we even saw a brief rebirth of the infamous "baby incubator" yarn...

7 comments:

gary said...

Well, clicking on the link it appears the story is "no longer available," which doesn't say much for its credibility. It looks like they pulled the story.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, something smells fishy. If anything, it would be the Baha'is that would be made to wear something to identify them, perhaps a big ol' bullseye. They are hated more than any other faith there.

.R.S.E.

Joseph Cannon said...

Jeez, two comments, before my post was even in its final form! Good catch about the Baha'is, R.S.E., and you are absolutely right. The Iranians are nuts about those guys. Always have been.

Anonymous said...

Oh we will all char together when we char
And let there be no moaning of the bar
Just sing out a Te Deum when you see that ICBM
And the party will be "come as you are"

--Tom Lehrer

Rob said...

Yup, they pulled the story, undeniably due to its falsehood. They were duped.

And the readers who picked up the morning paper and were led to believe, and I'm paraphrasing here, "IRAN IS THE NEW NAZI GERMANY!!" on the front page, were duped as well.

And the neo-cons win another one, I guess.

Expect a retraction in a small square on page A15 tomorrow or something, while right-wing Canadians foam at the mouth over the need to nuke these Nazi Iranians. And of course, it'd be nice if they could at least notify readers why they pulled the story online, rather than just deleting it altogether.

Anonymous said...

It's also worth noting that the "wiped off the map" quote frequently cited by the neocons is, at best, grossly mistranslated.

Of course, the neocons are really shooting themselves in the foot with all these overblown claims of Iranian plans to persecute innocent Jews. For the most part, the American public still does not realize that Iraq was invaded to further the geopolitical interests of Israel, but with Iran the cat is out of the bag - a fact that has a lot of pro-war Israeli lobbying orgs worried.

Joseph Cannon said...

Anyone who thinks that the public has wised up -- anyon who thinks that the Average Man and Woman know that they are bieng "played" on Iran -- should do what I did: Look at how many right-wing and middle-of-the-road blogs picked up the "Jewish star" disinfo tale.

Lots of people believe this stuff. Even after all the crap we have been through. Lots and lots and LOTS of people.