Wednesday, December 20, 2017

THE STORM! (Or: How do we get out of this mess?)

This is a long essay which uses a number of small examples to illustrate a very large problem.

Trump can cure cancer! Popular right-wing conspiracy freak Mark Taylor has assured his audience that President Trump will, in his second term, release the long-suppressed cures for cancer and Alzheimer's. For many years (says Taylor), these cures have been suppressed by the evil medical profession, which (as everyone knows) is controlled by those hideous, money-grubbing and endlessly scheming J....er, globalists.

You'd think that Trump would reveal the cure for cancer during his first term, and perhaps during his first week. Any president who can cure cancer would be a shoo-in for reelection. Any president who can cure cancer should be able to end Obamacare without opposition.

Taylor also says that "Satan's frequency" blinds Americans to Trump's many virtues: "This bombardment of frequencies that we have going on right now, it’s been proven scientifically that it will literally change your DNA, and that’s what’s happening to a lot of Christians." Curiously, Taylor neglects to cite the journal that published this landmark study of the effects of Satan's frequency on genetics.

Jedi. Alex Jones has decried the new Star Wars movie as state-sponsored propaganda. I cannot fairly evaluate this argument as I have not seen the film and would prefer to avoid spoilers. However, I worked on the outskirts of Hollywood for quite a few years and never once met, or heard about, a screenwriter who complained that the State changed his or her scripts. Screenwriters complain about everything else, but not that.

Since the GOP runs "the State" right now, Jones must think that the Republican party likes to fiddle with Star Wars movies. That's the problem with being a right-wing conspiracy theorist in age of Trump: You cannot scream about the menace of "THEM" when your team becomes "THEM."

Hillary. The continuing smears of Hillary Clinton have had an impact. Her approval ratings mirror Trump's. A large portion of our population continues to view this retired political figure as a major menace. Hillary-hate has replaced the orgasm as America's favorite form of emotional release.

"Gloom and misery everywhere." The newest, grandest conspiracy theory to enter the market -- by way of 4chan, natch -- is called The Storm. (The link goes a great piece published by New York Magazine.) Even though I do not yet fully comprehend this matrix of weird accusations, my "Spidey sense" tells me that this one is going to be bigger than Pizzagate.
Like Pizzagate, the Storm conspiracy features secret cabals, a child sex-trafficking ring led (in part) by the satanic Democratic Party, and of course, countless logical leaps and paranoid assumptions that fail to hold up under the slightest fact-based scrutiny. However, unlike Pizzagate, the Storm isn’t focused on a single block of shops in D.C., or John Podesta’s emails. It’s much, much bigger than that.
Now pay attention, 007:
On October 28, someone calling themselves Q began posting a series of cryptic messages in a /pol/ thread titled “Calm Before the Storm” (assumedly in reference to that creepy Trump quote from early October). Q claimed to be a high-level government insider with Q clearance (hence the name) tasked with posting intel drops — which he, for some reason, called “crumbs” — straight to 4chan in order to covertly inform the public about POTUS’s master plan to stage a countercoup against members of the deep state. It was, in short, absolutely insane. However, thanks to some rather forced coincidences — like Q kind of, sort of guessing that Trump would tweet the word “small” on Small Business Saturday, and this one time the internet decided that Q was “totally on Air Force One” because he posted a blurry picture of some islands while Trump was on his trip to Asia — and a whole heck of a lot of wishful thinking, people believed he was the real deal.
Within the conspiracy community, there is a myth (which I first heard in the late 1980s) that "Q clearance" is the highest level of clearance within the United States government. (A novel by Peter Benchley seems to have initiated this meme.) In fact, the term is used only within the Department of Energy to denote those granted access to nuclear secrets. Rick Perry, God help us, has Q clearance.
According to Q, Trump was never really involved with Russia, and isn’t actually under investigation by Mueller & Co. On the contrary, Q insists that it’s actually Clinton and Obama who were corrupted by Putin (and are now actually under investigation by Mueller) because they’re obviously just evil, money-hungry globalists who’ll do anything for the highest bidder. (Oh, yeah, and they’re also apparently into raping and killing children, though the crowd is split over whether this is because they’re satanists or just part of some weird blackmail scheme involving the CIA.) Q also claims that Trump, the genius that he is, figured all of this out way back when he was just a measly presidential candidate, and has been pretending to love Putin and/or be involved with Russia ever since as a way to force a third party to investigate these horrors — without drawing the attention of those evil Dems-who-must-not-be-named, of course — because he’s just that selfless of a leader.
In this fantasy world, all of the far right’s wildest dreams come true: Q promises that Clinton, Obama, Podesta, Abedin, and even McCain are all either arrested and wearing secret police-issued ankle monitors, or just about to be indicted; that the Steele dossier is a total fabrication personally paid for by Clinton and Obama; and that the Las Vegas massacre was most definitely an inside job connected to the Saudi-Clinton cabal.

They believe all of this will be coming to a head any day now. That “The Storm” — of arrests, political turmoil, and Republican vindication — is coming. Though there have been some, uh, miscalculations as for exactly when.
From time to time, this humble blog has received comments from crazed conspira-trolls confidently predicting that Hillary, Obama, Soros and their partners in evil will soon be rounded up and led off in cuffs. Now I know the origin point of these forecasts.

Have we met Q before? "Q" -- whoever he is -- has fastened upon a familiar ploy. Do you remember TBR News and "The Voice of the White House"? If the name doesn't ring a bell, allow me to ring it.

During the Dubya administration, this alleged "insider" manifested himself within the cyber-pages of a website called TBR News. Many visited that place without understanding that "TBR" stood for The Barnes Review, a pseudo-scholarly organization devoted to the promotion of Holocaust revisionism. The Barnes Review was the creation of a notorious neofascist named Willis Carto, who, in turn, was an associate of Francis Yockey, a mastermind of the post-war fascist underground.

(William Turner's Power on the Right describes a speech given by Carto in a hall bedecked with swastikas. Carto's Noontide Press catalogue offered Hitler: The Unknown Artist and other examples of Adolf Adoration.)

The editor of TBRNews called himself Walter Storch, who also writes under the name Gregory Douglas, and whose real name may be Peter Stahl. Another dubious writer calling himself Henry Makow is also associated with "Douglas." (There is talk of a family relationship. Hell, Makow may be Douglas.) I've read that these deceivers may have links to the rarified field of art forgery. In sum and in short: These people live in a world best described as "The Blacklist with brown shirts."

I tried my best to comprehend this goose-stepping masquerade ball in this long, weird post published in 2009. If you're fascinated (as I am) by All Things Strange, hit that last link. You may also want to read an excellent investigative piece published in 2006 by Kos.

Bottom line: The Storch/Douglas/Makow "team" -- if we can call it a team -- is devoted to the creation of elaborate fakes, deriving either from bogus documents or from ersatz "revelations" offered by nameless insiders. This blitzkrieg of bogusness has a fourfold purpose: 1. To foster paranoia. 2. To spread anti-Semitism. 3. To cast a favorable light on Nazi Germany. 4. To make Americans lose faith in democracy.

Back in the Dubya era, liberal websites often got suckered in by the Voice, which seduced lefties by telling them what they wanted to hear about Bushian malevolence. Since TBR News usually kept the anti-Semitism sotto voce, many lefties went along with the simplistic presumption that anyone who hated Bush just had to be cool. Until very recently, most progressives refused to understand that the ultra-rightists despise the Bush family as much as they despise the Clintons.

Why am I rehashing this history? Frankly, my Spidey sense is telling me that Q and the Voice of the White House could be one and the same. Of course, my Spidey sense is far from infallible. Even if it is wrong in this instance, I suggest that Q is best understood as a very gifted student of the Makow/Douglas/Stahl/Storch school of manipulation.

Pizzagate on steroids. Let's return to this important New York Magazine expose of a phenomenon which -- like early-stage Trumpism itself -- has managed to infect much of our culture while attracting little mainstream attention:
Over the last month and a half, the Storm has spread from the depths of 4chan and 8chan to Reddit, YouTube, and Twitter, where it’s found hundreds of thousands of devout followers. Some of the most popular explainer videos boast nearly 200,000 views, and the QAnon hashtag has gotten so popular, it’s honestly difficult to track. (I signed up for one of those freebie “Track Your Hashtag Now!” services and #QAnon hit the 2,000-post limit within four hours.) Some poor soul even took the time to write a 117-page book charting Q’s rise to power, which I’m guessing has been seen at least as many times as this very aggressive Imgur guide, which was at 137,000 views as of Sunday night.
It is claimed that Roger Stone has slyly pushed Q-friendly material. I don't know if that claim is true. If it is, color me unsurprised.

Bottom line: How do we get out of this mess? The above-linked NY Mag story caused one reader to offer this comment:
This type of thinking is ABSOLUTELY treatable with medication. Not kidding.
I doubt this. I believe that "conspiracism" -- like alcoholism -- should be considered a form of addiction, and I'm not sure that addiction can be cured by psycho-pharmacology.

For the sake of argument, let's stipulate that this assertion is true. Do we want to live in a country in which those who make dubious and dangerous claims are forcibly medicated? Who will decide which Americans receive drugs? Who watches the watchmen?

That, in a nutshell, is the conundrum we face in the era of Trump. I used to have faith that unregulated free speech was a self-healing organism. I used to believe that free speech was like Wolverine's skin: The bad guys could bruise it, batter it, stab it and shoot it -- but after a period of pain, everything would return to normal.

I've lost that faith. The bullets have hit vital organs and the holes don't seem to be closing up.

Conspiracy madness is destroying this country. Neo-Nazis are using (or abusing) free speech to eradicate democracy. In the end, they hope to institute a totalitarian state in which free speech will be no more.

Infuriatingly, the only way to combat their abuse of free speech is to restrict free speech. But that option is unthinkable. Any state which has the power to hide or prevent the lies told by Q or "Gregory Douglas" or the Pizzagators will also have the power to restrict what I have to say and what you have to say.

Perhaps the best film about Nazism is Kevin Brownlow's 1965 masterpiece It Happened Here. Toward the end of that movie, one character offers this horrifying paradox: "The appalling thing about fascism is that you've got to use fascist methods to get rid of it."

When I first saw the film at a revival theater in early 1980s, that line made me angry -- and I was not the only one who felt disturbed. A few in the audience applauded; some hissed.

How do I feel now? I don't know. I just don't know.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

“The point of modern propaganda isn't only to misinform or push an agenda. It is to exhaust your critical thinking, to annihilate truth.”

― Garry Kasparov

XI

Anonymous said...

They are preparing the field for armed rebellion. The extreme right has the military training and the weapons. Read the comment sections, talk with your nazi barber... Many are just waiting for the call to kill the libruls.

There's a reason why European countries have laws against hate speech.

Stephen Morgan said...

It's hardly far out to say the CIA tamper with scripts. They've been doing it since they changed the ending of Animal Farm. These days almost every major movie has either funding or technical and logistical support from the CIA, the FBI, the DoD or some similar organisation. Michael Bay doesn't put in all those military helicopters and slow-mo shots of flags because he likes them, it's product placement. Just one manifestation of paid patriotism.

The Last Jedi isn't an example of that, though. The CIA are better writers.

Anonymous said...

A new Pizzagate type Pedo conspiracy?

AWESOME! NOW WE FINALLY GET TO UNCOVERING ALL OF THOSE EX-SOVIET PEDO NARCO STATE UNDERAGE GIRL TRAFFICKING CONNECTIONS SURROUNDING THE ALLEGED CHILD RAPING DRAFT DODGING TAX CHEATING PUSSY GRABBING COMPROMISED RUSSIAN MOLE IN THE WHITE HOUSE! THIS IS GOING TO BE COOL! FINALLY ALL OF THE EX-SOVIET PEDO NARCO STATE UNDERAGE GIRL TRAFFICKING STORIES TIED TO TRUMP, ERIC'S PRINCE'S BLACKWATER, DYNCORP WILL ALL BE UNCOVERED. DEMOCRATS ARMED WITH THIS INFO WILL MIRACULOUSLY SPROUT A FULL SACK OF NUTS AND A SPINAL COLUMN, WILL FIGHT BACK AND DEFEND THEMSELVES! WE WILL LEARN ABOUT JEFFREY EPSTEIN AND THOSE UNDERAGE GIRLS BROUGHT IN FROM EX-SOVIET PEDO NARCO STATES TO BE CAUGHT ON VIDEO TAPE AND SCREWING AMERICAN POLITICIANS AND BUSINESSMEN BACK IN 2001-2003 DURING THOSE YEARS AMERICA WAS GETTING ROPED INTO AN EXPENSIVE QUAGMIRE IN THAT EX-SOVIET-QUAGMIRE STATE AFGHANISTAN. AWESOME!!!

GREAT NEWS! DEMOCRATS WILL TAKE THIS INFO AND FIGHT BACK! WHERE'S MY POPCORN MUNCHING SMILEY????? FUCK I DON'T HAVE ONE!

Oh wait.. We are talking about Democrats who don't know how to fight. All of this will be turned into an attack AGAINST Democrats and Democrats will find a way to knock off two or three of their own in the process..

Silly me. What was I thinking.

Anonymous said...

FUCK OFF YOU TERRORIST AMERICA-HATING PIECE OF SHIT TRYING TO HACK MY FUCKING COMPUTER. GET THE FUCK OFF IT, STOP PUTTING SHIT ON MY COMPUTER AND TYPING SHIT INTO MY ADDRESS SEARCH BAR YOU FUCKING AUTHORITARIAN AMERICA DESTABILIZING PIECE OF TERRORIST SHIT. AND DON'T CALL MY PHONE AGAIN.

Where's my 911 Researcher Smiley? Where did I put that shit?

HERE'S HOPING THE U.S. GOVERNMENT GETS IT SHITS TOGETHER AND UPROOTS THIS FUCKING AMERICA HATING AND AMERICA DESTABILIZING , WESTERN LIBERAL WORLD HATING AUTHORITARIAN TERRORIST GARBAGE TYPES THAT INSTALLED THE AUTHORITARIAN MOLE IN THE WHITE HOUSE . HOPE MUELLER PULLS THIS WHOLE GODDAMN AUTHORITARIAN GARBAGE UP BY THE ROOT!!!

Sorry everyone for that, back to regular programming. A terrorist scumbag was hacking my computer so I am going to capitulate and go away. I said what I needed to say.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays everyone! Except to the America hating authoritarian terrorist piece of garbage fucking with my computer who is probably a western liberal world hating narco pedo block supporting asshole who wants to turn USA into Russia, China, Egypt, UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Kazahkstan or some other authoritarian type garbage terrorist third world wealth stealing child raping narco state.

Peace!

:)

Anonymous said...

One more note, that may be of use to some ....whoever was on my machine just now is gone. How do I know? Because my machine is now very fast after feeling sluggish for quite awhile. They turned tail and ran and now my machine runs smooth like butter which implies they have been at it awhile. Now I just need to do some anti virus on my machine and see if I can see what they did to my machine and get whatever shit they put on it off...won't be using Kasperksy to do it though. :)

Make of it what you will. I''m out.

Peace.

b said...

"The appalling thing about fascism is that you've got to use fascist methods to get rid of it."

If I may be permitted to argue by analogy, I think the falseness of this proposition becomes apparent if one considers an amended version:

"The appalling thing about psychotic social conditions is that you've got to act psychotically to challenge them."

State repression of fascism is a peculiar idea but in the US it could only mean taking the guns. In an abstract sense that would be great, but in reality an effort to introduce such a law would be a fascist dream come true and it would bring forward the coming fascist bloodbath. The fascists clearly want to "bring it on". Neither repressive legislation nor a reduction of the state's involvement in society (more "freedom") can solve the fundamental problem of an ever more terrifyingly widespread and deeply fucked-up gullibility.

Which is not to oppose state action against capitalist rapacity, which should, as ever, be called for - such as the nationalisation of the banks and schemes to ameliorate poverty.

Citing Rosa Luxemburg (1918), Guy Debord wrote (in 1967) that an epoch had opened after WW1 in which the "social reign of appearances" determined that the "central question" (which is "capitalism or socialism?", or as Luxemburg also put it, "socialism or barbarism?") can no longer be posed "openly and honestly".

When the mass of the world's moronic young fuckwits spend hours every day picking at their "smart" phones and doing free work for CIA-helping advertising companies such as Facebook and Google - the phrase "They Thought They Were Free" comes to mind - no "central question" is about to be posed any time soon.

We are in such a fucked-up epoch, that d'you know what? The best answer there is to the contingent question of "what the fuck do we want to happen that may slow, contest, or even reverse the drift?" may be leftwing lone wolves.

Joseph Cannon said...

I don't know if your re-phrasing of the quote from "It Happened Here" is apt. If I recall, in the film the statement is made to justify IRA-style terrorist actions against the Nazi regime in the UK. (It's an "alternative history" story in which the Nazis won.) If you don't think that an anti-Nazi resistance should engage in such acts -- well then, what SHOULD they do?

When it comes to the current situation in the US, I am convinced that guns are not the issue. The worst thing liberals and moderates can do right now is give voice to any proposition that will lend credence to the right-wing conspiracy theory that the "great gun round-up" is a-comin'.

The issue is propaganda. That's how Trump won. That's really the main arrow in his quiver. For that matter, that's how Putin solidified his power in Russia: He took over TV.

Can we learn anything from the example of America's actions leading up to and during World War II?

For the most part, this country did not impinge upon free speech rights, despite the threat to our democracy. "Signal" magazine was distributed freely. There was talk about banning Mein Kampf, but a host of intellectuals (including Albert Einstein) argued against that measure.

Some newspapers were definitely tilted toward Hitler. Hearst is the obvious example. Robert McCormick published military secrets right up to Pearl Harbor.

American fascist leader William Dudley Pelley was tossed in the pokey in the early days of the war. I forget the charges, but I seem to recall that they were dubious.

Father Coughlin is a special case. He was on the radio, and the FDR administration decided that broadcasting was "the public commons," and therefore radio stations had to get operating permits. That's what shut him up. This move had repercussions which lasted a long time, until the airwaves were replaced by cable and by the internet.

I guess the Coughlin case best illustrates the principle I'm trying to define. If FDR were alive today, he'd probably offer a simple answer: Declare the internet -- or at least the big American social media platforms -- to be "the public commons," requiring regulation and operating licenses.

If anyone these days proposed such a thing, that person would be called "Fascist!" Arguably, with justification. I, for one, would not feel good about any proposal to regulate Facebook or Twitter or Reddit. On the other hand...

...look at what happened in 2016. Look at how the Alt Right gained its muscle.

And that brings us right back to where we started. "The appalling thing about fascism is that it forces you to adopt fascist methods to get rid of it."

Anonymous said...

If you are playing a game of soccer and a fascist cheats and punches you in the face, punch him back in the face, then kick him in the crotch and lay his ass out flat, eject the fascist fucker from the game... then everyone else can reinstate normalcy and get back to playing the game like like normal. Best thing Mueller can do for the country is take all these bad actors out of the game and lock them up. Stop allowing them to break all the rules the rest of us play by.

b said...

Which quote from It Happened Here (1964), which I haven't watched? If it's "They Thought They Were Free", I got it from Milton Mayer's nonfiction book with that title (1955), about everyday life in Nazi Germany.

Got to admit, I'd like to see the government crack down on the airwaves, including the microwave phone network through which many people get a lot of their internet nowadays - and which already works by public licence. The companies that beam shit to young people and corrupt their minds using smartphones, in the largest schizoid offensive in the history of our planet, do it having bought licences from the state. Wifi uses microwaves too, so licence that as well.

A ban on wrestling and other depictions of violence and degradation on TV and the internet (crucial to the Trump phenomenon) could help reduce the brutality in society. Banning text messages would help reverse the terrible decline in literacy.

The media, or the propaganda sphere, or communications technology, call it whatever - the old-fashioned term "interactive TV" may be apt, and points up the schizoid psychological internalisation - has crossed a boundary. In this sense we are already living under fascism. Long live leftwing lone wolves who don't talk to others of their persuasion very often, or perhaps ever, who are NOT part of a cell network, and who hit enemy targets, without focusing on violence exclusively, and certainly not focusing on guns and stuff, because there are many other avenues that can be used, some involving moderate violence, others involving "random acts of kindess".

There is "bossnapping" too - a welcome example of an imaginative form of popular struggle that has recently arisen, and which has usually been successful.

Guerrilla methods can be employed to get things out into the open - such as "micro" things, such as what really happens when a person goes into a local branch of a bank, or what happens behind the scenes in supermarkets.

We are very long way from "glasnost" about social problems. Books by Michael Moore, Naomi Klein, Slavoj Zizek, etc., are on sale in the shops, but we don't have a left-wing "civil society" sphere at the moment. There's not the same consequential opposition to "the man" as there was half a century ago. Young ignorant fuckers are too busy being used by big business on "their" phones, thinking they're "free" as they allow themselves to be.

Recognition of how, say, companies such as Google and Yahoo encourage voyeurism of violence and humiliation could grow as soon as people start looking at the front pages of their "news" websites with minds just a little bit attentive and active.

It is not beyond the bounds of possibility that popular forms of boss-hitting and scumbag-hitting and being nice and social could emerge that in some cases look like the advertising-dominated "flash mobs", or even the disgusting bullying "happy slapping" pushed by 4chan etc., but which work in the opposite direction entirely.

At least this is what I think in my rare moments of something other than cosmic pessimism.

There were leftwing lone wolves in the form of the Animal Liberation Front before the extreme-right neo-Nazis discovered the model.

Just some thoughts...

And Merry Christmas!