Cable news coverage of the New Orleans disaster has been infuriating -- yet oddly dichotomous. The reporters on the ground clearly want to tell what's really going on, even as the talking heads want to stick to the RNC-approved script. We find ourselves in a badly-directed play, in which the chaotic production ruins the onstage illusion.
Remember the Soviet media's pathetic inability to hide the dimensions of the Chernobyl disaster? History repeats itself.
I heard one FEMA official praise his agency's reaction, since, after all, this crisis was (supposedly) managed much better than was the southeast Asian tsunami. First: Since when do American agencies rate themselves by third world standards? Second: In many respects, what has gone on in New Orleans was in fact worse than the reaction to Asia's malady. Third: Tsunamis are caused by earthquakes, which are unpredictable -- as opposed to hurricanes, which (in the modern era) give advance warning. Why didn't buses remove the population of New Orleans before the disaster struck?
This problem was created by the federal government, not by local government. This MSNBC report makes that fact crystal clear.
Yet the conservative spinners want the American people to blame Bush's victims in New Orleans. That's why black people are labeled "looters" when they take necessities from a store, while white people are identified as strugglers for survival.
Bush finally -- belatedly -- flew into the stricken area, promising only to restore "law and order" -- not to restore the bare requirements of survival. When governmental foolishness robs its people of their shelter, food and water, then "law and order" becomes impossible. No-one should accept death and humiliation with docile obedience.
Even so, CNN Pentagon correspondent Jamie McIntyre said that news coverage showed too much sympathy for the victims!
Although Bush-lovers will refuse to let the figures sink into their chromium-plated noggins, the fact remains: Bush created the disaster in New Orleans by refusing to fund efforts to shore up the levees. Although conservatives pretend that the shortfall only affected projected budgets, not past and current budgets, history punctures that hallucination.
Figures vary from report to report, but the ones published in today's Los Angeles Times seem reliable. In 2001, the Army corps of engineers asked for $20 million to fund the Lake Pontchartrain project: Bush gave them about $4 million. In 2003, the Army Corps of engineers asked for $15 million; Bush allotted $5 million. In both cases, Congress eventually allowed for the release of more money -- but not much more, not enough to do the job. For example, in 2005, Bush wanted to fund the levee project at $3.9 million dollars; Congress allowed $5.7 million. The Army Corps of Engineers said $27 million was needed.
Now we will have to pay at least $25 BILLION to rebuild New Orleans.
Even left-wing pundits operate under the delusion that the levee funding was withheld to pay for the Iraq debacle. Let's all stop repeating that canard.
Capitol Hill has been pork city ever since the Republicans took charge -- as one commentator said during the last budget battle, they've even stopped pretending to be financially responsible. For example, the Republicans approved the building of a $230 million bridge in red-state Alaska -- a bridge designed to service an uninhabited island. (Note to Alaskan readers: That's California money you're spending there. Not all leeches are Southern.) What justifies the expenditure of that kind of money in a country where the New Orleans levee system is denied a mere $27 million?
No, the problem wasn't Iraq.
The time has come to consider the unthinkable. Did the Bush forces want to force the ethnic cleansing of New Orleans?
Consider the "laissez faire" approach to evacuation. The well-off could afford to drive out of town; poor people -- predominantly black -- lack both transportation and the means to afford shelter. They had to stay and survive the onslaught. And then the cable news bozos tried to convince America that these people "chose" to stay.
Why did the Bush administration not set up a transportation and shelter system before the disaster struck? We had plenty of advance warning for this hurricane.
Consider, too the following damning statements from the Red Cross, explaining why they were not in New Orleans to feed the starving and shelter the helpless:
Access to New Orleans is controlled by the National Guard and local authorities and while we are in constant contact with them, we simply cannot enter New Orleans against their orders.The last sentence makes no sense. I suspect that the Red Cross, for political reasons, is simply repeating Homeland Security lies. Relief agencies have been stepping into disaster zones for many decades now without impeding evacuation efforts.
The state Homeland Security Department had requested--and continues to request--that the American Red Cross not come back into New Orleans following the hurricane. Our presence would keep people from evacuating and encourage others to come into the city.
Are we really supposed to believe that Bush administration disallowed the entry of food and medicine because they felt that the black people of New Orleans -- stacked up like cordwood in the disease-infested Superdome and environs -- would love this largesse so much that they would decide to stay?
What a lie. What a lie!
In fact, the National Guard have prevented the victims from evacuating on foot. Read this horrifying account, and ask yourself: Are we really seeing hte results of mere mismanagement?
So the victims could not escape their hellholes, and could not receive any outside assistance. Why did Homeland Security stop the Red Cross from entering New Orleans? Perhaps for the same reason the Nazis would not allow the Red Cross to enter the camps. Perhaps the sign at the entrance to the Superdome should have read "Arbeit Macht Frei."
(For further evidence, read the "update" below.)
Perhaps ethnic cleansing was the purpose. The new New Orleans, we are told, will be a gentrified zone, free of the impoverished:
And we all know that the prevailing model for urban development is to get rid of poor people. The disaster provides an opportunity to deploy this model in New Orleans on a citywide scale, under the guise of rebuilding the city and its infrastructure.Dennis Hastert has already proposed bulldozing the place. You know -- put up some nice condos. Get rid of the riff raff.
In place of the jobs that have been washed away, there could be alternative employment through a huge, federally funded rebuilding effort. But this is George Bush's federal government. Does anyone believe that the Bush men would mandate that priority employment go to the pre-flood, mostly Black population of the city?
And the no-bid rebuilding contracts went to Haliburton, of course. If you ask me, instead of asking blue state taxpayers to toss more money at that corrupt corporation, we should demand that Cheney's cohorts fork over some of the money stolen during the Iraq debacle. Nobody knows quite how much money went missing in Iraq, but the figure is well into the billions. Instead of asking California and New York to pony up more dough, why not recover some of that missing cash and use it to help rebuild the stricken areas?
UPDATE: For further evidence that the ethnic cleansing of New Orleans was deliberate, check out this story. I'll relay substantial excerpts:
On Wednesday morning a group of approximately 1,000 citizens pulling 500 boats left the Acadiana Mall in Lafayette in the early morning and headed to New Orleans with a police escort from the Jefferson Parish Sheriff's Department. The flotillia of trucks pulling boats stretched over FIVE miles... The group was comprised of experienced boaters, licensed fishermen and hunters, people who have spent their entire adult life and teenage years on the waterways of Louisiana.Meanwhile...
The State Police waved the flotillia of trucks/boats through the barricades in LaPlace and we sped into New Orleans via I-10 until past the airport and near the Clearview exit. At that time we were stopped by agents of the FEMA controlled La. Dept. of Wildlife & Fisheries. A young DWF agent strolled through the boats and told approximately half of the citizens that their boats were too large because the water had dropped during the night and that they should turn around and go home.
They were pulling a large (24ft) shallow draft aluminum boat that can safely carry 12 passengers and had ramp access which would allow the elderly and infirm to have easier access to the boat. They then politely informed the DWF agent that the local and national media had consistently reported that the water level had risen during the night which contradicted his statement to them that the water was dropping and no boat over 16ft. in length would be allowed to participate in rescue operations.
They then specifically asked the DWF agent that they (and other citizens in the flotillia) be allowed to go to the hospitals and help evacuate the sick and the doctors and nurses stranded there. They offered to bring these people back to Lafayette, in our own vehicles, in order to ensure that they received proper and prompt medical care.
The DWF agent did not want to hear this and ordered them home -- ALL FIVE HUNDRED BOATS. They complied with the DWF agent's orders, turned around and headed back to Lafayette along with half of the flotillia....
I can't come up with one logical reason why the DWF sent this large group of 500 boats/1000 men home when we surely could have rescued most, if not all, of the people trapped in Charity Hospital. Further, we had the means to immediately transport these people to hospitals in Southwest Louisiana.
On Tuesday afternoon, August 30, Jefferson Parish Sheriff Harry Lee asked for all citizens with boats to come to the aid of Jefferson Parish. A short time later Dwight Landreneau, the head of the La. Depart. of Wildlife and Fisheries, got on television and remarked that his agency had things under control and citizen help was not needed...
The despicably racist Lou Dobbs blames the problems in New Orleans not on Bush, not on the underfunded levee system -- but on New Orelans mayor Ray Nagin and on the entire black population of that city. They brought the problem on themselves. Why? Because, you know...they're black.
Disgusting!
I've noted other cable pundits going after Nagin, who has done tremendous work under agonizing circumstances. One TV idiot (was it O'Reilly? I can't recall...) even suggested that Nagin had not performed up to Guiliani's standard.
Unbelievable!
Rudy Guiliani is the jackass who deliberately placed his city's emergency management center in the World Trade Center -- even though everyone knew that the WTC was the prime target for terrorism. Imagine the outcry if the mayor of Los Angeles placed the command center for our emergency response services atop a known earthquake fault...
I'm surprised Guiliani wasn't lynched after 9/11. How do the Republicans keep managing to spin their sinners into saints?
28 comments:
Thanks for addressing the lunacy of the Diefication of Guiliani, post-9/11. I thought his management of NYC (which also involved an ethnic cleansing of the poor--and disabled police officers from the city's population) was questionable before the attacks. After? Dead to me.
Have you considered that the degradation that the citizens of New Orleans have been made to endure is a domestic Abu Greib (or however it is spelled)?
Oy.
A-B-U G-H-R-A-I-B.
Joseph, the Republicans do nothing that is not politically expedient. Period. They delayed their response to Katrina due to incompetence and the fact that they really didn't give a shit about it.
Not an election year. Not swing states. Screw them.
More of my take at progprog.
Speaking of Giuliani, how weird is it that a former federal prosecutor should destroy the
evidence of what made the WTC
collapse--destroy it over protests from Fire
Engineering magazine? The NIST report claims that the steel was weakened by the fire, but the fact is that NONE of their core steel samples show evidence of heating
to those temperatures. Since the steel
was marked with stamped numbers, extracting the pieces of interest from the
pile should have been relatively easy.
But thanks to interference by a
politically ambitious mayour who should
have known better, we'll never know for
sure what brought the towers down. Let
alone WTC7. The steel was hauled away and recycled so fast the firemen rioted, protesting that the scoop and dump operation was desecrating the remains of
their 343 heroes.
There's an element of Guiliani's post 9/11 behavior which is little known: his suppression of study of and response to the toxic pollution which occurred in downtown NY. This included a de facto collusion with federal authorities to give the public baseless assurances at the time, and working actively to keep federal agencies out (the ones who actually try to do their jobs).
There was a virtual news blackout on this subject in the NY Press, for months afterwards. Any reporter who raised it was quickly slapped down and vilified, despite the thousands of people in downtown NY with chronic coughs and far more serious debilitating complaints.
(Also little known is the fact that Christine Tood Whitman had and has a large financial stake in the NY/NJ Port Authority, and a very strong interest in suppressing accurate environmental studies.
So lax was Guiliani, he let both "volunteers" and city fireman work on that smouldering pile without any protection at all -- in their street clothes, which they took home to their families, dust and heavy metal. No respirators, nothing. And, of course, tens of thousands of more, living in the neighborhood, who got no help at all and were told there was nothing to worry about.
Ten to 20 years from now, when the tens of thouasnds of cancers start coming in, the victims will remember Guiliani fondly.
As for the rest of his tenure in NY -- he lost some 30 lawsuits, in his attempt to withhold information the public was legally entitled to, he publically vilified the judges who ruled against (they're prevented from responding, because of professional ethics), he tried to shut down the Brooklyn Museum because he didn't like one of the exhibits, he routinely vilified his critics, he blamed victims of police violence for their pwm injury deaths and injuries, and he appointed incompetent toadies to high positions (remember Bernard Kerik?).
The basbard even threatened to cut short relief efforts or sabotoge the political process (it was election season), if he wasn't allowed to stay on for mayor 3 extra months -- or more.
Today, he's just another Bush flunky. I'd say we have quite enough of Rudy.
This was supposed to be posted here but, my mistake I guess, got posted to the "Anger" story.
===
I don't know about the reliability of the following, but I thought it was interesting:
http://www.total411.info/2005/09/provacateur-forces-in-new-orleans-case.html
Sunday, September 04, 2005
Provocateur forces in New Orleans? The case builds
On Thursday, there was a report on the net Delta Force had just dropped into New Orleans. This was at about the same time this website noticed a couple helicopters full of unidentified troops being dropped off the helipad at the Superdome. If the "Delta Force" story is true (and even Army Times says forces are engaging in combat in New Orleans), or another small special ops force were dropped into New Orleans, they would be well placed, for provocateuring more than anything else. Such as laying down sniper fire on boats evacuating patients from a hospital or setting fires, or sniping at firefighters.
This item is from the LiveJournal blog of someone holed up in a functioning datacenter on Canal St. at 1pm CDT Saturday:
"The Riverwalk may be on fire (shopping mall at the river at end of CBD/Quarter). Everytime we talk to the police, we hear about sniper fire at the fire scenes. I cannot confirm that there is any. This is all hearsay, but it's coming from the police. The police we talk to, while consistent about claiming there is sniper fire, are conflicted about whether it's police sniper fire trying to take out arsonists or criminal sniper fire trying to take out police and fire rescue teams. Again, this is rumor for now, but we're hearing a lot of this rumor.
Delta Force is a criminal organization, having previously engaged in the murder of Americans at Waco, so any fire from them would by definition be sniper fire.
It seems like someone is going up and down the river, setting prime real estate on fire and making sure they burn down. First the warehouses, now the Riverwalk shopping mall, a structure orginally constructed for the 1984 World's Fair.
Are there other special forces teams out there that could take out these provocteurs? Anyone that gives a damn about America or New Orleans? Could someone call France and ask for a hand?
===
Also on the questionable side, but it rings true: see the report of a supposed White House insider (is this true? really?) about an overheard conversation in an elite dining-place. True or not, it rings true. It's at:
http://thetruthseeker.co.uk/print.asp?ID=3548
These bigshots need pulling down, don't they?
thanks for this.
i've been uncomfortable with the sniper stories from the get-go; just doesn't wash. and the anonymous who shared the story of delta forces, now that sounded more plausible to me. the only facts i'm basing this hunch on are that there are multiple reports on how many ways in which relief efforts have been rejected (e.g., doctors, local boaters, the red cross, walmart's water, not to mention chicago and canada and cuba and chavez, etc.), the lockdowns, and the convenience of the sniper stories with so little, as far as i know NO actual eye witness confirmation.
on top of the really horrifying stories like the shooting of a man for just trying to flag down a truck to help rescue a woman being gang-raped (bbc).
i got an email diary of some folks who got stranded, and they ended up on a bus that was going through the city picking up folks for cash because fema would not allow any busses in. the driver was taking all back roads to avoid getting spotted and charged because of the risk to him in getting caught.
now, at americablog, one poster brought up the slightly disconcerting fact that tulane was doing research on bioweapons, including eboli, using animals. what happened to all these creatures, mammalian and viral?? can any of these things spread via water?
i have a grave mistrust of the truthseeker votwh site (i believe dailykos established their questionable pedigree some time back), but the racist rant he describes nonetheless rings true.
the financial gain theme from both 9/11 and nola is certainly consistent with what we would expect from these folks, at least as much as the racism.
this is worse than abu ghraib in certain ways. this is like watching darfur. or like watching bush not even capable of watching darfur.
this, folks, is genocide, pure and simple.
ps.
and joe, again, please calm your rhetoric. though i agree that there is a very urgent need for anger right now, we are all best served when that anger is most efficiently focused on doing the most good. ultimately, trashing all red-staters is just not productive. you can, and have in the past, made the point with great eloquence.
take a deep breath and regroup; focus like a laser.
it makes the writing more difficult, i agree, and one does need to ventilate now and again, but i have every faith that you are up to the monumental challenge.
home equity loan in california
Information => home equity loan in california
I have a miscellaneous food store site. It pretty much covers miscellaneous food store related stuff. Check it out if you get time :-)
So many blogs and only 10 numbers to rate them. I'll have to give you a 9 because you have a quailty topic.
Free Access To More Information Abouttravel alarm clocks
I am wiser on the subject of shopping online pittsburgh now that I've read your blogshopping online pittsburgh
I will make sure to read more of your materialamazon online shopping I like this sort of information. amazon online shopping
Yo, This blog is pretty neat. You should check out mine sometime. It pretty much covers internet business income opportunity related stuff.
Hey i noticed your site is about french connection united kingdom i found somewhere if your in the UK that allows you to send spoofed sms!
send a TXT "EN SPOOFING 07712345678 Hi i really fancy you" to 69911, Hi i
really fancy you is sent to 07712345678 and the user gets a standard reply.
Changing 07712345678 with the number you want to send too!
The SMS Costs £1.50 per msg but its really good!
I hope you enjoy this :) i did so pass on the word!
Remember its UK Only
Came here searching for car cheap loan uk cause i need a car cheap loan uk
Best ive found so far is
car cheap loan uk
Nice blog on loans in the UK good for car cheap loan uk
Hey good post. Look at my site if you can. Thanks! free gambling money for online casino
I research my automotive questions viper motorcycle
I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about from home income job residual successforfreedom.com work related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.
Yo, This blog is pretty neat. You should check out mine sometime. It pretty much covers best business opportunity related stuff.
Hello - Great blog on mortgage home loans denton. Keep up the good work. I also have a mortgage home loans denton site that I think would interest your readers. Stop by if you get a chance
"I just came across your blog about income marketing mlm network residual tip and wanted to drop you a note telling you that I was impressed with the information you have posted here. I also have a website pertaining to this topic about income marketing mlm network residual tip so I know what I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are prooviding a great resource on the Internet here!"
Great blog! I often write about payday loan indiana. Check out my payday loan indiana site. It mostly deals with payday loan indiana.
I just came across your blog about advance d6oya faxless loan loan loan payday payday payday tinyurl.com and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a web site about advance d6oya faxless loan loan loan payday payday payday tinyurl.com so I know what I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here! If you get a chance, please stop by advance d6oya faxless loan loan loan payday payday payday tinyurl.com
I just came across your blog about catalog shopping and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a web site about catalog shopping so I know what I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here! If you get a chance, please stop by catalog shopping
Hello,
Great blog with some useful info on no income verification home equity line of credit. I have a no income verification home equity line of credit themed site you and your visitors might find interesting. I'd love for you to check it out.
Great Blog. I have found a site on southeast asia travel . You may find it useful at southeast asia travel
Post a Comment